Because Madden 22 had an athlete Madden 22 coins on the cover so it's unlikely EA would ever repeat something like this ever again. This cover has only seen two times before and If they continue to put both athletes in the covers it will detract from the importance it has when it happens. You also have to take into consideration that Brady Mahomes and Brady have both been featured twice on the cover, it will be highly unlikely that it would be one of them.
As we take a look at the past players who have been on the cover previously, it doesn't seem as if this is a year we are going to see an athlete that has appeared before. There's only one athlete who has been on the cover before that I can see being featured on the cover, but all the others would be brand new for Madden 23.
5. Matthew Stafford
A cover athlete is generally supposed to be a representation from the previous season. If that is the case and the reigning winner QB of Super Bowl LVI has to be added to this list. Matthew Stafford left the Detroit Lions to help bring a Super Bowl to Los Angeles and he accomplished that. It was even more impressive that it took him just one year to achieve this.
Quarterback is , in all likelihood, the most cheap mut coins crucial post in soccer, particularly during the modern era. Matthew Stafford proved that there was a quarterback problem during his time in Los Angeles and his debut as a player fixed the issue and many other crucial pieces that the Rams brought in as well. I could see Stafford being one of the best options for the Madden 23 cover. Also, if EA will choose an athlete who was part of the previous NFL season overall Matthew Stafford's name is bound to be being discussed.